Quote Originally Posted by Lewtskie View Post
I just think its better than trying to take advantage of people just wanting to enjoy a new job.
This is the problem.

Because a dungeon takes 1 tank, 1 healer, and 2 dps. It's impossible for everyone to enjoy the new jobs at launch. The number of players who will be willingly playing tank and healer when these new jobs are dancing in front of them will drop for a while after launch. Yes, there will be players that queue as tank purely out of the goodness of their heart for complete strangers. But many players are still driven towards self-benefiting rewards, and instant tank queue only goes so far.

So some players, instead of playing the shiny new jobs, are instead going to play a job that they wouldn't otherwise for the sake of making Gil. You scorn them, but I believe these players would likely just not tank if they were not selling their queue. To ask them to queue as tank for no additional reward, when they would rather do something else, is asking them to take a bullet for the sake of your own desires.