Results 1 to 10 of 109

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    Risvertasashi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    4,706
    Character
    Makani Risvertasashi
    World
    Ultros
    Main Class
    Conjurer Lv 50
    Fair, but

    Quote Originally Posted by Altena View Post
    The absolute kicker for me was when the sprout gave the mentor advice.
    It's funny, but this really just shows how arbitrary it all is. The sort of person that's willing to give friendly advice, and seek out knowledge when they notice they don't have it... I'm OK with such people being mentors even if they're not walking encyclopedias. But setting very long time requirements or other things will just mean people like this you see will be old *and* still bad at it. Meanwhile, newer but skilled players that might have picked up a lot of knowledge quickly... would be locked out.

    If there's a good way to filter "willing to help" I might be OK with that, but I can't think of a way. Adding very high instance, time, commendations, whatever... won't filter out the selfish and lacking.
    (0)

  2. #2
    Player
    Altena's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Posts
    1,362
    Character
    Altena Trife
    World
    Excalibur
    Main Class
    Lancer Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Risvertasashi View Post
    It's funny, but this really just shows how arbitrary it all is. The sort of person that's willing to give friendly advice, and seek out knowledge when they notice they don't have it... I'm OK with such people being mentors even if they're not walking encyclopedias. But setting very long time requirements or other things will just mean people like this you see will be old *and* still bad at it. Meanwhile, newer but skilled players that might have picked up a lot of knowledge quickly... would be locked out.

    If there's a good way to filter "willing to help" I might be OK with that, but I can't think of a way. Adding very high instance, time, commendations, whatever... won't filter out the selfish and lacking.
    Well yes however you don't just suddenly gain a title because you are "willing to help". You could be clueless but still willing, which is where the problem lies. A playtime filter would at least filter out people who PotD'd their 3 rolesand spammed a bunch of dungeons. I guess my point in this is the requirement is just flat out too low. Yes some people that are willing and likely knowledgeable will have to wait until they get to that point - however on the reverse end of the argument you won't have as many people who meet the requirements that don't have a clue.

    You don't just get something because you are "willing" to get it. You have to earn it as well.

    I think what other people suggested is a great idea - having a lower entry for the "willing" people, and a much higher requirement for becoming a PvE or PvP mentor. Sure, those "willing" people are more than welcome to offer advice in a dungeon, however it will weed out a lot of the sprouts that look to the mentors for advice, while the mentors are busy eating a bunch of avoidable damage.

    It is definitely nearly impossible to get a perfect balance in this case, however the chances of a player with higher playtime being more knowledgeable about the game is more likely than a sprout who is.
    (0)

  3. #3
    Player
    Risvertasashi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    4,706
    Character
    Makani Risvertasashi
    World
    Ultros
    Main Class
    Conjurer Lv 50
    Quote Originally Posted by Altena View Post
    You don't just get something because you are "willing" to get it. You have to earn it as well.
    In my mind the current requirements do that. You have to have experienced the game from 3 different roles from low to high level, and people have to have been happy enough with you to have commed 300 times. Even if someone does PotD spam 2 of those, they'll still have to have done all the regular content on at least 1. It's not perfect, but it is a foundation of a somewhat balanced experience. And very importantly: At the very least they can share experience, and tips they've learned or things they wished they new, with new players now going through the same thing for the first time. To me, that's highly relevant -- new players have a lot to get to before they can worry about the max level stuff and beyond. Even if it is as simple as "This is how to use PotD to level your second job and beyond quickly".

    I guess where we disagree is... if someone hasn't learned by then, I don't think simply upping the tickmarks they need to check off will do much.

    (Now, really: I really think SE could do with moderating the novice network and mentors in general. I've seen MMOs run by much smaller companies that have had hired and paid staff to watch their newbie channels, or an "official volunteer" program for moderators... would be nice if SE could step up to the plate there.)

    Edit: As a side note, though, thank you for keeping the discussion civil. Too often these sorts of things on this forum... can get a lot more heated.
    (0)
    Last edited by Risvertasashi; 02-07-2017 at 01:07 PM.

  4. #4
    Player Brian_'s Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2015
    Posts
    710
    Character
    Graylle Celestia
    World
    Tonberry
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 70
    So just to clarify --

    We need to clear up some fundamental lapses in logic in this topic.

    First off, if you increase the requirements for mentor status, does that guarantee you'll have better mentors?

    As a whole? Yes.
    On an individual basis? No.

    But the important point is likeliness. Is it more likely that someone who has run 5000 instances as a tank will know more about their job's performance in content than someone who has only run 10 instances? Yes. Obviously. Is it more likely that someone who has run an instance 100 times will know more about that instance than someone there for the first time? Yes. Obviously.

    This is the same backward logic people use to support baddies who have terrible dummy parses. They say that just because someone has an impeccable dummy parse doesn't mean they'll parse well in a live fight. Yea, parsing well on a dummy doesn't guarantee they'll parse well in a live fight. But, it increases the likelihood that they can. Meanwhile, if you have a terrible dummy parse, you aren't suddenly going to have an amazing parse in a live fight. You're still going to have a terrible parse.

    It's about likelihood.

    If your goal is to teach players how to play their jobs well, will a requirement like clearing Alexander Savage guarantee that the mentor will be proficient on their job? No. But, the likelihood that they are is higher. Are there players who haven't cleared that are as good or even better than some people who have cleared? Sure. But, as a relative percentage, the percentage of cleared players who are of a proficient skill level is significantly higher than the percentage of uncleared players who are of a proficient skill level.

    Unless you are using a very detailed screening system, increasing likelihood is the best you can do.

    And the next lapse in logic -- that skilled players aren't necessarily skilled teachers. I actually agree with this point. But, I'd just like to point out that while they might not be skilled teachers, you can still function as a great text book. And, a great text book potentially helps a self-motivated student much more than a skilled educator who is teaching them incorrect things. This is why PoV videos are a thing. There is no commentary. There is no explanation or hand holding. What it comes down to is whether or not the student can decipher the information he is given rather than have the teacher spoon feed it to them. Stuff like fflogs is a veritable treasure trove of information but few know how to really learn from it. There are plenty of players I have never met or talked to that I have learned more from than any mentor.

    So, even if I had no idea how to play DRG, I could still point a player struggling with DPS in Sophia EX or Zurvan EX to a few good fflogs parses and tell them to pay attention to general up-time, buff timing, buff syncing, buff up-time, DoT up-time, geirskogul count, and average damage on certain skills with positional requirement. I could tell them to look at the event tab for the GCD by GCD break-down for key moments in the fight.
    (3)