Unofficial Census 2016 for FFXIV

[Ibi]

Raiding needs proper incentives. This 5ilvl weapon difference between 240 and 245 should be extended to all midan gear. There should always be a new savage mount, just like wow does for mythic. There should always be a new savage title, just like wow does for mythic. The BiS of one raid tier should help you in the next raid tier, just like in wow. The highest ivl in the game should only come from savage raids, just like mythic raiding in wow. The midan savage sets should look different from the normal models, just like how the models look different across normal/heroic/mythic raiding in wow.

We don't have a way to compare participation rates (because there's no way to get that information for XIV unless SE decide to tell us), but aren't the completion rates for Savage raiding in XIV extremely comparable to the completion rates for Mythic raiding in WoW, despite Mythic raiding having all these additional rewards that Savage doesn't?

[zosia]

We don't have a way to compare participation rates (because there's no way to get that information for XIV unless SE decide to tell us), but aren't the completion rates for Savage raiding in XIV extremely comparable to the completion rates for Mythic raiding in WoW, despite Mythic raiding having all these additional rewards that Savage doesn't?

So, your argument is that since clear rates are similar we should skimp on standard raid rewards in this game? Factoring in Heroic, since it's rewarded similarly to mythic, participation rates in wow raiding are higher than FFXIV raiding.

[Zumi]

We don't have a way to compare participation rates (because there's no way to get that information for XIV unless SE decide to tell us), but aren't the completion rates for Savage raiding in XIV extremely comparable to the completion rates for Mythic raiding in WoW, despite Mythic raiding having all these additional rewards that Savage doesn't?

Mythic completion rate Its actually something around 0.001% because they have even more casual players. Count only people who raid its something like 1%. So i guess having the highest ilvl and BiS gear drop all in 1 place doesn't make more people beat it. FFXIV the savage difficulty seems fine I see a lot of groups in PF looking for people to do it so there is plenty of interest in doing it.