Repair NPCs in Dungeons

[Zantitrach]

Someone mentioned the Aery before. It'd be easy to have a Dragoon follow you and hold the entrance; do recall - we all made it in, including Eistinien. Dragoons would definitely want to make a move on Nidhogg's lair, so it makes plenty of sense for them to be there.

No, it doesn’t. We practically had a suicide mission to the Aery. While Dragoons would WANT to go there IN-FORCE, they would have to retcon a LARGE portion of the story to get more dragoons in there.

The aery? Could easily put the same dragon that TAKES YOU TO THE ENTRANCE OF THE DUNGOUN and could be seeking to help you repair.

What?

I've actually yielded that putting it in places like Void Ark, Midas, Gordias, etc. wouldn't be very good. Those are raids, and are considered midcore content. They're also short enough that it's not really going to require an NPC - well, at least in the case of Gordias and Midas.

What? Those places have constant mechanics wipes. Great place for repairs. And what about Bismarck EX? Ravana EX? TEX, IEX, etc. Those are not raid content. But there’s 0 reason for an NPC vendor to be within a stone’s throw of Ifrit.

I mean, would it be completely unreasonable to have G'raha Tia at the entrance to World of DArkness and able to help repair your gear?

Yes, yes it would. He has no training, and would have to have a HUGE amount of his lore changed (he has a lot of it in various snippets through the unlocking of the Crystal Tower raids) to meet this criteria.

I've never met a pure crafter who doesn't do battle, unless they were an alt. Does my evidence make yours invalid?

This was in response to OP’s

How often do you see pure crafters anyways? I don't know about you, but I can count on one hand the number of people who exclusively craft I've met.

This is purely circumstantial and not a data-center wide constant. You should read the points that I respond to for context.

"Takes away their benefit" (Even though, really, it doesn't.)

I’ve got 3 people in my raid group alone who ONLY leveled crafting so they could repair during battle, etc. They. HATE. Crafting. So yes, it ONLY takes away their benefit. SE gonna refund them the time it took to do that?

Same reason they can stand at the entrance of a dungoun to enable the dungoun instead of coming in and helping us out. How does that not 'raise eyebrows' with anyone?

Because we’re the all powerful Warrior of Light, and they’re Nobody Boot-stain with 0 capability to assist IN the dungeon.

Negligence to do something is not necessarily willfully doing something. It just implies someone made a mistake, which is a human error.

You’re right here, but ironically negligence also implies YOUR failure to do something. YOUR failure, YOUR responsibility. YOU need to fix it. If you are negligent AND you still don’t fix the issue, then yes, it is WILLFILLY doing it. As you are WILLFULLY not fixing your negligence.

I've already contested these points multiple times, but people just parrot them and get refuted just as quickly. That's part of a debate, though, is stressing your point and proving/disproving with evidence.

There's no refutation, they say one thing, you say the opposite, neither of it is 100% fact, its all opinion. Your proving your point with “Evidence” is just as paper thin as everybody else's.


And I'm going to sound like a jerk here, but now that I see that its intentional from all your posts Eidolon, there is no d-u-n-g-o-u-n.