Quote Originally Posted by Pells View Post
This is mostly correct. For WARs and DRKs.

For a PLD, Bloodbath healing is pathetic, since they have no real spammable ae damage skills.

You've also forgotten the extra self healing through natural in-combat regen a full VIT tank would have over a full STR one, amounting to roughly 40% more. (22k/16k, given the max hp numbers in your post)
This applies 2% of their max health every tick, anytime the tank is not at full health--amounting to roughly 120hp/tick more self healing for the VIT tank. An extra 25% healing through single-target Bloodbath isn't going to overcome this loss.

As a result, a full VIT PLD is slightly easier to heal than a full STR PLD.

The bigger difference is still whether the tank can use their defensive CDs appropriately.
Aren't DRK's aoe attacks magical, therefore not effected by Bloodbath? iirc.