Quick question to all dps people in regards to dps in general

[whiskeybravo]

You should also keep in mind that there are 2 factors to War's that contribute to their high Dps output that most people do not consider.

Neither of the points are relative for a tank in tank gear, though. I can do perfect combos, have perfect timing for fell cleaves and 100% uptime, but if I'm not wearing str gear then I just look like a crappy war. Conversely, I can wear full str, put out half the effort and have amazing looking numbers by comparison. Now, without getting into what's the right or wrong way to play, it should be easy enough to see this has very little to do with the job itself and everything to do with what gear your're wearing. If you want to compare pld, drk, war dps with each other, either in vit or str, then that's fine, I just think the dynamic changes when you compare dps geared tank to dps geared dps, it's more or less just dps vs dps at that point, not tank vs dps.

In my opinion, content is overgeared the moment when solid groups start to sell/7-man it. This has been the case in savage for quite a while now.

I would only say that those particular people are overgeared for their skill level, as well as anyone that has had a4s on farm for a while and thus has all the gear available. Would you tell a player with i205 + thordan weapon who has never stepped foot in alex savage that they overgear it? Surely they have the gear to be able to clear it given enough practice, but would you really tell them they overgear it?