Quote Originally Posted by RiceisNice View Post
Snip
And I still argue that someone who wants out or to troll you is going to accomplish that by any means necessary regardless. They will purposely wipe the group to get you to kick him and then you are still in the situation you are trying to eliminate: you are down a player and that player is out of the group with no penalty. You said yourself there's no way to tell what's a legitimate wipe and what isn't, so it's no different than that player purposely wiping the group so you kick him. This wouldn't open the floodgates like you fear.

Again, these situations you are describing are a completely different (and obscure) issue that won't be solved until you fix players. Since we can't fix players, we have to make a system that's better for the good players instead of a system that is just slightly worse for the trolling ones. Ten bad guys go free rather than one innocent, yadda yadda and all that.