Let's call this game, "Final Fantasy XIV: DPS Forever".

On a serious note, it seems that many people want EVERY job to be a DPS before their main role. I personally see nothing wrong with the game having a defensive-focused tank, and offensive-focused tank, and a MP-based tank. After a while, folks are going to make people feel bad by forcing them to focus tanking and putting greater focus on being a DPS.

I like my PLD for what it does, not what I SHOULD make it do. Learned that lesson a long time ago with WHM.