Astro in savage

[RichardButte]

The thing you need to take into account is alot of these people start off with AST and are only having issues due to DPS messing up and taking damage that they shouldn't and then they switched to WHM after the DPS have gotten what to do down and then it seems easier not because they are WHM now but because the DPS are now better at avoiding damage.

So your argument is that, even though these people have said that they immediately had no trouble after switching away from AST, the run on which they all switched just HAPPENED to be the same run that the DPS in every single raid group wised up and stopped getting hit by the mechanics?

...Really?

I have watched plenty of streams with WHM SCH and still wipe over and over for the same reasons AST and SCH wipe it's called DPS messing up it happens and it can cause wipes no matter what healing team you bring in.

Yes, and when people go from wiping constantly with an AST to having little trouble with a WHM or SCH, what else could be blamed except for the AST?

No one is saying that every group with SCH/WHM is going to clear it every time, nor that every group with an AST will fail miserably every time.

The point is that we have a number of examples of people who tried with AST, found it hard or undoable, and then, with all other variables unchanged, switched to a different healer and cleared the content.

This confirms that the AST is a weaker healer and is in need of being brought in line with the other two.