Quote Originally Posted by NoctisUmbra View Post
Sure it is situational. More often than not the stun is preferred. Hell I keep Haymaker, Jarring Strike & Simian Thrash on bar. Most of the time when tanking I will use Haymaker > Jarring Strike on an evade but given the TP and the desire to do damage Simian Thrash is a very viable option.

Making it just another WS, like I said earlier, makes it another Victimize II with a long, flashy animation. It takes away any unique aspect it had to it.

In my opinion, situational high damage counter > long animation Victimize II.

Also, when compared to Jarring Strike II, Simian Thrash adds more than just a "bit of damage."
Well, I know it can be situational and all, I'm just stating the preference that most of the player base has when comparing Jarring Strike and ST, though, I do love to use Victimize, though, if they made it a bit flashier, I would like it a bit more, but that is actually just staying on topic with my OP, I said Victimize was boring and they should change ST because it looks fancy/has the potential to. I also just think using ST 1 out of 10 times is a bit stupid.