SMN redesign in expansion?

[Romsca]

I think there is some legality preventing Square Enix from using any suggestions from players as we are not employees of Square Enix. I can't think of a single mmo that did that.

[Natsuno]

I think there is some legality preventing Square Enix from using any suggestions from players as we are not employees of Square Enix. I can't think of a single mmo that did that.

I can think of one. World of Warcraft.

Two instances that come to mind, and I only remember these as they are to do with the only class I really gave two flicks about:

Rolling Blood Pact into Dark Intent. This was suggested via Twitter (iirc). Sometime during MoP.

There was a warlock 'tank stance' spell that got its name (Dark Apotheosis) from an MMO-Champion forum poster, when one of the developers in charge of the MoP warlock overhaul used to frequent the warlock sub-forum around about beta MoP to early MoP. Sadly, this spell no longer exists in game.

Actually, as far as all these long lists of spells that people are coming up with, they would probably have better luck if they didn't give specific values to the spells they suggest. These are probably more likely to be rejected outright without a second thought (Overpowered... Underpowered... Meh... lolwut?!). Leaving things more vague, along with a reason as to why you feel this change is needed probably allows the developers to do what they do, and more likely to incorperate the idea if it aligns with their vision for the class/job.