% for melding materia is broken

[Tiggy]

And so you should not "expect" it either.

It's only going to be on average 41 out of a 100 as well. Small sample sizes leave plenty of room for outliers of streaks to complicate the picture.

Which brings me to another point no one has mentioned. Not a single person here has properly recorded their successes and failures at each % of success.

For example. at 99% success I've done 200 synths. My data shows I have a 95% success rate from my 200 synths so far. Even this is too small of a sample size to be statistically significant.

This is the only kind of data that matters. Not anecdotal evidence for a couple of synths. That means literally nothing to statistics.

Proving the RNG is broken is a statistical problem. You must, through statistics, prove there is an imbalance. I won't believe a single complaint until people start recording this data to show if a true bais exists or not. Otherwise it's all subjective and anecdotal.