Garuda Extreme final phase melee question

[Etgar]

That's because you ate 2 Wicked Wheel at the same time. One is from Suparna, and the other from Garuda. They both cast Wicked Wheel at the same time.

If you read what I wrote again, you will see that I mentioned the off-tank taking Suparna, so that both Wicked Wheel will be separated, thus you will only be eating one Wicked Wheel (2500 damage in your case).

Nope, one WW is 5K+ not sure what dps you were playing.