Sacrificing .79 DPS for 507 HP

[Pellegri]

To make such claims, you have to present evidence.

Who are you talking to exactly? if it's the person above your post then the evidence is in every single Twintania kill that has happened so far or even what everyone says you need to successfully get past the conflag phase on a consistent basis. 4k health is the breaking point for where you have a 100% chance at surviving a fireball when a group is stacked with 4 players/pets. Anything more than 4k just raises the margin for error and allows you to be lower than full health when taking a fireball.

However as a dragoon in full bis(as the op says he has) you have over 5k health already. That is quite a bit over the breaking point needed for fireballs and anything higher is just wasted when it comes in the form of losing dps or healing. If you can follow the mechanics though there are 3 phases that are a dps race(conflag/snakes/dreadknights), all 3 of these phases require everyone to push as much damage as possible as fast as they can. What is an extra amount of health going to do when it comes to dps races when you already have well over what is required to successfully survive the only mechanic that requires a decent base health?

Outside of a few mechanics on each boss, all damage is avoidable and the unavoidable dmg has honestly a fairly low ceiling for how much health you need to survive it. What is a health buffer going to do for a dps or healer when they should be avoiding all avoidable dmg in the first place? It's your job to move out of things while continuing to push out damage or healing, if you need extra useless health to accomplish that because you suck at moving out of things sometimes then there's problems that need to be dealt with beyond stacking more health.