Quote Originally Posted by Churchill View Post
I wasn't really having an uninformed discussion so much as I was making an informed statement.
And what was it informed by? You said that WAR does more damage and generates more ST threat, which has been shown numerous times to be pretty damned untrue, assuming the PLD actually uses the tools available to them. Fight or Flight, Circle of Scorn, and Spirits Within are all *amazing* force and threat multipliers. On top of that PLD gets to spam their high enmity combo ad infinitum.

I've run both a PLD and a WAR and run *against* PLD on my WAR: PLD manages better ST threat because they get to use their high enmity combo on a constant basis. If you think it's an informed statement to say that WAR has better ST threat, you're not informed: you're woefully uninformed. The damage dealt between the two is effectively identical with PLD being slightly worse when tanking without a WAR around and slightly better when tanking with a WAR.