Sigh....

"People that think it is broken - Where is your proof/math?"
"People that think it works - Where is your proof/math?"

I haven't seen anyone post anything that provides proof. Cant really go asking for proof if you wont provide proof of otherwise.
The word of mouth from people that did it is enough proof. R1 weapon and R50 weapon vs NM = Same damage.

Me, I can vouch that it is broken, because I went and did it.