This is a really odd argument to make. PLD has a truck load more of CDs to survive off of any encounter. But if that PLD is as geared as the OP, that CD means nothing once it's gone. You're talking about a few seconds out of a fight that you're praying to stay alive with. Besides the gear you have curently is not even optimized for tanking. Half of your accessories and other slots are normal crappy DPS pieces. No where near enough mitigation or farming done to even begin to cry "Broken Class". Plenty of streamers on Twitchtv that have full Darklight, in every slot and their Relic weapon, making good attempts in Bahamuts Coil. Surprised this thread event lived for so long on this silly argument. This is like comparing Warrior and Druid tanking in Wow back in Vanilla/BC