Seriously 3-5 minute repop on NMs?

[Visch]

This is going to happen regardless of the timer. I'm sorry, but you're playing a MMO; you're not going to be a special little snowflake.

It's nice to know there are people out there more concerned with everyone getting everything than making a good game.

I think a 10-minute respawn rate would be adequate. I agree with other players that 3-minute and 5-minute respawn rates for ANY notorious monster is a bit too accelerated. But I disagree with players that desire 30-minute (or more) respawn rates for mid-rank NMs. That seems somewhat counter to the purpose of mid-rank NMs.

I whole point is that the gear is rare no matter what level you are. The point of an NM is you have to actually try for more than 15 minutes to get something not just roll up and have a "challenging fight" and get it.

[Sojiro]

It's nice to know there are people out there more concerned with everyone getting everything than making a good game.

Its nice to know there are people out there more concerned with being unique snowflakes than making a good game.

I whole point is that the gear is rare no matter what level you are. The point of an NM is you have to actually try for more than 15 minutes to get something not just roll up and have a "challenging fight" and get it.

That would imply the drop rate on said item is 100% which they are not. Currently 0/4 on PGL claws from cactuar jack, someone else that was camping him was 0/17. As far as I know the rest of the NM's have equally abysmal drop rates. At the end of the day I would rather try the fight more often with lower drop rates (keeping it rare) than trying once every 2-3 hours with a higher drop rate with the chance of losing claim and waiting yet another cycle.

In any case, I think 2 hours should be the absolute maximum respawn time for the highest rank NMs. Any longer than that, you make those NMs practically inaccessible to any player that works 9-5 and has children ... no matter their rank.

But thats what they want. Only people able to dedicate 6+ hours of their day to the game are allowed to even see those NM's. Just to be, once again, unique snowflakes.

[Visch]

Its nice to know there are people out there more concerned with being unique snowflakes than making a good game.

What is a good game to you? Everyone getting everything no matter how much they play?

That would imply the drop rate on said item is 100% which they are not. Currently 0/4 on PGL claws from cactuar jack, someone else that was camping him was 0/17. As far as I know the rest of the NM's have equally abysmal drop rates. At the end of the day I would rather try the fight more often with lower drop rates (keeping it rare) than trying once every 2-3 hours with a higher drop rate with the chance of losing claim and waiting yet another cycle.

OH MY GOD 0/17?? That is so horrible! It might have actually took you more than an hour to get what you want!! How could SE do this????!??!?! OMG!!>!?!>!>!>

If you think anything in this game is "rare" you're out of your mind.

[Arcell]

What is a good game to you? Everyone getting everything no matter how much they play?

I know this wasn't directed at me but I'm going to answer it anyway! A good game to me is a fun game that involves challenge. I don't care if I get the drop on my first run or my 100th run as long as it's fun. I also don't care if my items are rare or not. I'm not so emotionally needy that I MUST be the only one to have a certain item. Fun has nothing to do with how rare my gear is, it has to do with how fun it is to play the game.

[Sojiro]

What is a good game to you? Everyone getting everything no matter how much they play?

Everything being accessible to people, even if they can't devote 6+ hours a day to the game. There is a difference.

OH MY GOD 0/17?? That is so horrible! It might have actually took you more than an hour to get what you want!! How could SE do this????!??!?! OMG!!>!?!>!>!>

If you think anything in this game is "rare" you're out of your mind.

Only people walking around with the new stuff are people who get extremely lucky with drop rates, or have spent considerable time getting it. These are after all mid-level NM's, your statement a couple posts back, "that it should take more than 15 minutes" (your words here) is definitely happening the majority of the time i'm sure.

[Visch]

When you say "try" do you mean "wait"? I'm not being sarcastic, I'm actually honestly asking. I just want to know.

http://wiki.ffo.jp/img/975/nm_ll.jpg

A lotto spawn. A longer timed spawn. Anything that makes actually getting to fight the NM a nice surprise.

I'm my opinion, NMs are more about the "challenging fight". If your party wins that fight they get the spoils.

This doesn't make an items rares.

I guess one could argue that the spoils become more psychologically valuable if you had to wait an excessive period of time before you had a chance to fight and get those spoils. Personally, "waiting" seems a more illusionary achievement than actually defeating the NM. But that's just me.

Defeating anything doesn't mean anything. Everyone can do it. No matter how strong something is everyone will be able to do it after someone figures it out. It doesn't make anything rare.

And how matter how "rare" a drop it is after it's killed just means the same people are going to camp it for a month rather then a week.

I also don't care if my items are rare or not.

And why is this? Because you want everyone to have everything without trying.

Everything being accessible to people, even if they can't devote 6+ hours a day to the game. There is a difference.

And what do you want later on? Missions like we have now that anyone can do? To reach this game's "sky" or "sea" and have NMs with instant repop that drop pop item for harder NMs?

Anyone could access anything XI. There was nothing ever telling anyone if you have to play 6 hours at once to do this.

Only people walking around with the new stuff are people who get extremely lucky with drop rates, or have spent considerable time getting it. These are after all mid-level NM's, your statement a couple posts back, "that it should take more than 15 minutes" (your words here) is definitely happening the majority of the time i'm sure.

It should take more than 15 minutes to even see NM. Not get the drop for yourself and everyone else in your party.

Great post Gildrein and now hopefully the majority wanting a challenge will cool off. However, the hardcore(niche group) probably won't and will just cry more and more. Bring out the warm milk because it's time to put these babies to sleep.

It really doesn't matter how "challenging" anything is or how easy it is to get anything. No matter what someone is going to get something before you and be better then you.

[Zenaku]

http://wiki.ffo.jp/img/975/nm_ll.jpg

A lotto spawn. A longer timed spawn. Anything that makes actually getting to fight the NM a nice surprise.



This doesn't make an items rares.



Defeating anything doesn't mean anything. Everyone can do it. No matter how strong something is everyone will be able to do it after someone figures it out. It doesn't make anything rare.

And how matter how "rare" a drop it is after it's killed just means the same people are going to camp it for a month rather then a week.



And why is this? Because you want everyone to have everything without trying.



And what do you want later on? Missions like we have now that anyone can do? To reach this game's "sky" or "sea" and have NMs with instant repop that drop pop item for harder NMs?

Anyone could access anything XI. There was nothing ever telling anyone if you have to play 6 hours at once to do this.



It should take more than 15 minutes to even see NM. Not get the drop for yourself and everyone else in your party.



It really doesn't matter how "challenging" anything is or how easy it is to get anything. No matter what someone is going to get something before you and be better then you.

man forget about it thanks to wow this is what players think, you should see wow players there even more crazy. Even wow have rare mobs that take hours to pop and item that take hours to get i know for one took 5+hours to get a pet item the drop rate was like 15% or something so ya ffxiv is even more casual then wow.

players think a game need to be a big timesink for everyone when they could easy make bcnm fight for casual and others can have 1-4hours NM and 5-6hours HNM and they can do the bcnm version with about the same drop rate.

[Visch]

ffxiv is even more casual then wow.

:|

players think a game need to be a big timesink for everyone when they could easy make bcnm fight for casual and others can have 1-4hours NM and 5-6hours HNM and they can do the bcnm version with about the same drop rate.

Yup... Exactly what they did in XI later. This is probably the best option.

[Sojiro]

man forget about it thanks to wow this is what players think, you should see wow players there even more crazy. Even wow have rare mobs that take hours to pop and item that take hours to get i know for one took 5+hours to get a pet item the drop rate was like 15% or something so ya ffxiv is even more casual then wow.

players think a game need to be a big timesink for everyone when they could easy make bcnm fight for casual and others can have 1-4hours NM and 5-6hours HNM and they can do the bcnm version with about the same drop rate.

I'm completely fine with an instanced version available of the same encounter (could even make it a bit more challenging) for the same item, even keeping the drop rate the same between the two, hey i'm all for it. What surprises me is Visch, who wants to be completely unique in the game, agrees with an option to allow people to get the same gear without the same "effort" it takes to stand there waiting on a pop. This option (while I highly approve) still doesn't keep that gear "rare".

[Arcell]

And why is this? Because you want everyone to have everything without trying.

Way to put words in my mouth, real nice tactic. I never said I want everyone to have everything without trying. I was saying that personally I'm not so emotionally needy that I can't stand to see other people wearing the "rare" stuff I have too. Having fun in the game is not about how rare your gear is, it's about how fun the game is to play. Given enough time a vast majority of the community will have an item. People who play longer should get an item faster than others, but they shouldn't be the only ones to get it.

I'm all for challenge, I know you aren't. Would you be happy if the NM had a .0000000000001% drop rate, spawned every 30 hours but died in 1 hit? Not challenging at all but the gear would be rare as hell! You could feel special in your "epic lootz"