Job Dungeons

[Doki]

What would happen:
Day 1: 1000 WHM all spam the instance for completion
Day 10: almost every WHM has completed the instance
Day 100: You spend about 10 hours begging people to job change to their WHM to help you through, but the group falls apart after only getting up to 5 WHMs for a few hours.

[Elexia]

Oh right, because everyone will level all the classes and jobs--oh wait...

It's almost like you never played FFXIV.

Anyway, this is a bad idea merely for the fact stacking is what ruined most content in XIV and why it forced people into classes and jobs they didn't want to play, especially if there's good other incentives.

Here's what you do and something XI did well with some bosses:

You simply create a dungeon with a boss that changes it's immunities or strategies to damage/counter abilities throughout the fight forcing a mixed setup since you can't change while inside or/also include in the dungeon spots where you have to fight a subboss to change the bosses immunity/weaknesses to x. In XI for example it was collecting your lights from the Palace in order to counter Promathia's various chain abilities.

Stacking or Mage/Melee only chambers is a recipe for 1.0 disaster.

[Venat]

What would happen:
Day 1: 1000 WHM all spam the instance for completion
Day 10: almost every WHM has completed the instance
Day 100: You spend about 10 hours begging people to job change to their WHM to help you through, but the group falls apart after only getting up to 5 WHMs for a few hours.

Each Job gets there own Dungeon... wouldnt be 1000 WHMS on day 1 cus noone plays WHM. 2... Its not like the drops would be easy toget... think darklight... Day100... Join a LS toget your raids done cus shouting isnt gonna get you skilled players.

[Antanias]

Each Job gets there own Dungeon... wouldnt be 1000 WHMS on day 1 cus noone plays WHM. 2... Its not like the drops would be easy toget... think darklight... Day100... Join a LS toget your raids done cus shouting isnt gonna get you skilled players.

Or use the Duty Finder.

[Pseudopsia]

Each Job gets there own Dungeon... wouldnt be 1000 WHMS on day 1 cus noone plays WHM. 2... Its not like the drops would be easy toget... think darklight... Day100... Join a LS toget your raids done cus shouting isnt gonna get you skilled players.

You do realize the development effort it would be to create a dungeon for each of the 8 jobs? I would much rather get 8 dungeons that any combination of class/job can play.

[Keith_Dragoon]

What would happen:
Day 1: 1000 WHM all spam the instance for completion
Day 10: almost every WHM has completed the instance
Day 100: You spend about 10 hours begging people to job change to their WHM to help you through, but the group falls apart after only getting up to 5 WHMs for a few hours.

D-U-N-G-E-O-N . F-I-N-D-E-R

Crisis averted!