Hurr durr asking for market studies. Look around for products that are being released, how do they work, why do companies choose to make them run like that? Hell even PSO2 is now giving direction on where to find the NPC you need to find, despite the world being really small...
It's not an all or nothing approach, it's an ALL approach, and then if you don't want to follow directions, disable the feature, done.
The right way of doing thing is always to give more possibilities to players, while providing a way to disable features that some of the audience do not want to use. That way you make more players happy.