[devPLEASE] Dynamic World - If Ever You Do Something - Do This!

[Alhanelem]

It does, because there is lots of stuff to the quest system, there isnt "Go talk to X, go kill Y, finish back at X" which is XIV's tool, that is skipped by not even talking in GW2, and then there is tons more features on top which make the questing system so much more unique and better.

You can white knight out your ass for sure, but you cant sit there and say XIV is doing it right and doesnt need improving.

I'm not white knighting, but you sure are black knighting. Nowhere did I, or even anyone else in this thread say ffxiv is perfect and doesn't need any improvements. However, it doesn't have to copy some other game in order to improve.

At least that'll be the case until the set of quests resets back.

Therein lies my point. You do get the "living" feel, but you have a cycle that eventually repeats. Nothing you do has a permanent impact. GW2 seems to me to be masking the flaws of an old system more than truly correcting them. I'm not saying it's a bad game either, but you're basically coming into this thread, slamming FFXIV, and lavishing GW2 with praise, without a lot of substance to explain your position. Any time someone pokes holes in your argument, they're "white knighting." I've seen this time and time again.