Quote Originally Posted by Duelle View Post
All this does is bring back "fodder tank vs boss tank", which is just as bad as WAR being picked over PLD for the tank role.
No... it would depend on the boss....

Like in a fight with an NM that has ultra high (Physical and Magic) defense, you'd want a WAR because the DD's are probably not going to have to worry about pulling hate since their DPS will be lower

But in a fight where the DD's are holding back or going red, You'll want a PLD for the extra enmity.. which gives the DDs extra breathing room

So both would still be viable in both fights... one would just excel more than the other depending on the situation....

There is no other scenario where both are viable....