Warrior do Fell Cleave. You can try and spin that it's ever done much else but in the distant past I was also pressing Fell Cleave > Fell Cleave > Fell Cleave, keeping up the buff, building rage, pressing Infuriate and Berserk/Inner Release.

Job identity has been eroded in favor of "balance" and responding to players who think it's unfair that their job doesn't have something another job does. As far as I've seen, Yoshi-P hasn't even been denying that, although one of the articles that quoted him he said misrepresented what he said.

As for what others think, if you look at literally any other post on these forums you will notice they don't think positively about any of it. Because most people obviously come to the forums to complain.