We need to do something about Tanks and Outgoing Damage from Bosses

[Supersnow845]

Thanks.
I thought, a solution that solves the problem without taking something from tanks away will be better 'all in all'. : )

On one side people don't want homogenization. But, on the other side, making tanks weaker in 'tanking' would just be a homogenization.
It's: Make tanks more similar to everything else.
I do not want this. :c

How is making tanks weaker “homogenisation”, they are already copies of each other. “Badly implemented immortality” isn’t a design paradigm. Nerfing them all roughly equally would just be a rebalance

[Khutulun]

Thanks.
I thought, a solution that solves the problem without taking something from tanks away will be better 'all in all'. : )

On one side people don't want homogenization. But, on the other side, making tanks weaker in 'tanking' would just be a homogenization.
It's: Make tanks more similar to everything else.
I do not want this. :c

So tanks becoming more dependent on healers is homogenization, but the fact we can heal others just like healers isn't?

[CaptainLagbeard]

Thanks.
I thought, a solution that solves the problem without taking something from tanks away will be better 'all in all'. : )

On one side people don't want homogenization. But, on the other side, making tanks weaker in 'tanking' would just be a homogenization.
It's: Make tanks more similar to everything else.
I do not want this. :c

I don't really see how making Tanks more into Tanks and less into Healers would make them more or less homogenized...

[Rithy255]

I don't really see how making Tanks more into Tanks and less into Healers would make them more or less homogenized...

I'd argue that tanks and healers should largely share a similar purpose of support, Tanks are already "tanks" in the fact they tank damage so well because the actual Mitigation value of tanks is absurd that plus sustain no wonder why tanks practically invalidate what little healing healers do.

Tanks aren't really "healers" but Healers aren't really "healers" both are pretty largely defined as support dps in function, as most of their role task is done with a few buttons they interact with the game in a very similar way to dps where every decision to be made should be to Solidify their damage output, as tanks have no reason to do anything other then to damage outside of clicking free defensives, Healers are in the same boat, outside of "gcd healing decision making" which practically doesn't exist if your a average or above healer.

The game is also designed in a way that's so one dimensional that you can't have Tanks that may perform a more supportive role towards the team while other tanks could have other focuses such as being a stronger main tank, good at damage (good at damage would always be hard meta in this sort of game)

I'm speaking from what I want from tanks though I personally lean to more supportive roles in general but will never really vibe with full on "mage-like" healers which is the only thing ff14 offers in terms of healers, So as a tank I actually really love the idea of using abilities that protect my team, through mitigation and healing, I don't find tanks fun if all the do is mitigate self and aggro the boss playing a largely selfish role.

[Alice_Rivers]

Tanks aren't really "healers" but Healers aren't really "healers" both are pretty largely defined as support dps in function

Healers aren't "healers" because there's nothing to heal, in large part because what healing there is to do is done by tanks who de facto ARE healers at this point and getting worse. I don't mind if tanks help with healing, I very much mind when tanks take over healing. You wanna pop a party shield that saves me GCD heal so I can just use an oGCD? Great, you wanna TBN that idiot with three vulns so I don't have to follow up specifically for him and can just cast an AoE heal? Happy days. Multiple benedictions every 25 seconds? Hell, HALF a benediction on a 25s cooldown? NO.

Further to this point, I don't mind tanks having lots and lots of mitigation, particularly if it's as heavily called upon in high end content as people are claiming. Tanks should be hard to kill but they never be impossible to kill, even at the peak of skill, without a healer. If this requires a rebalancing of tank HP and/or damage from enemies then so be it.

[CaptainLagbeard]

I'd argue that tanks and healers should largely share a similar purpose of support

This argument would work if Healers could get a way to do enough enmity to steal aggro from tanks.

[Rithy255]

Snip

Well I agree that Healers aren't healers because theirs nothing to heal, though what would be fun is actual decision making on healers the problem is both tanks and healers have overbloated kits which lead to things like GCD heals vs Damage GCDs not a choice because you can do both, I also fully agree that theirs a line with how much healing tanks can have I've said many times bloodwhetting is a awful cooldown that invalidates healers, warrior also just has a ridiculous amount of sustain beyond that, other tanks are partly guilty of this PLD/GNB but in their case we can effectively nerf mitigation value and sustain value without taking stuff from it's kit, while warrior's defensives/self healing need drastic changes. (I'd argue DRK's in a good spot for self healing).

Tanks being mitigation bots instead of more support oriented is the whole reason why you never heal tanks not because of tank sustain alone, both play a part in making tanks feel more strong I would reduce both and add for tanks to do more then just hold aggro, press your massive mitigation cooldown and healing buttons, I would honestly say current tank design is just miserable and dull for any tank player.

This argument would work if Healers could get a way to do enough enmity to steal aggro from tanks.

Here's the thing enmity is literally managed by one button that has no effort it's almost parallel to how healers basically don't heal but if not more so.

While I don't think tanks should replace healers tanks helping healers do their jobs effectively isn't a bad thing, that being said the way its currently handled is just horrid for both tanks and healers I think the system needs a massive overhaul rather then just removing sustain or mitigation it's really not a simple task of fixing this mess of a trinity system.

[CaptainLagbeard]

Here's the thing enmity is literally managed by one button that has no effort it's almost parallel to how healers basically don't heal but if not more so.

While I don't think tanks should replace healers tanks helping healers do their jobs effectively isn't a bad thing, that being said the way its currently handled is just horrid for both tanks and healers I think the system needs a massive overhaul rather then just removing sustain or mitigation it's really not a simple task of fixing this mess of a trinity system.

The thing is though, that removing sustain from tanks WOULD fix the problem of tanks having too much sustain.

[Rithy255]

The thing is though, that removing sustain from tanks WOULD fix the problem of tanks having too much sustain.

So we shouldn't actually try to fix the core fundamental issues and just remove sustain so you still never actually heal much because the outgoing damage is still too low?

You do realise just removing sustain (other then making tanks more miserable then they already are to play) will just lead to a Band-Aid fix where healers maybe more needed for ultimate's but wouldn't entirely be anymore fun, it's a really low bar for me to just advocate for removing tank sustain and ignoring the problem.

Maybe you'd be content with healers going from never needing to heal, to placing one ogcd heal on the tank extra, personally I want better for both tanks and healers.

[CaptainLagbeard]

So we shouldn't actually try to fix the core fundamental issues and just remove sustain so you still never actually heal much because the outgoing damage is still too low?

You do realise just removing sustain (other then making tanks more miserable then they already are to play) will just lead to a Band-Aid fix where healers maybe more needed for ultimate's but wouldn't entirely be anymore fun, it's a really low bar for me to just advocate for removing tank sustain and ignoring the problem.

Maybe you'd be content with healers going from never needing to heal, to placing one ogcd heal on the tank extra, personally I want better for both tanks and healers.

I know it's not the only issue, but it IS an issue that should be fixed. And the fix is literally as simple as cutting down the sustain on the tanks.