Would you consider greedy DPS Mechanics on Tanks/Healers good or bad?

[Ath192]

This is about Mana Shift and Goad. They are functionally the same thing except one is for TP and one is for MP. You liked one, but not the other with special attention to Mana Shift on Black Mages.

This has nothing to do with the MP and TP system and all to do with how illogical it is that 2 actions, that are functionally the same, can harbour different opinions.

Wait... what? Did you read what I said? I am going to quote for you:

"The only thing I didn't enjoy was TP and goad - the concept of your player getting too physically tired to attack was a bit too much for me."

It's the TP system and goad by extension as a part of it I didn't enjoy. Not goad in a vacuum.

That's not the conversation I was having. You need to work on understanding context clues here. Unless you didn't mean to reply to me and were trying to make some random take for the general reader.