How do we develop Better Casual Content?

[AllenThyl]

According to lalachievements:

53.1% - Pick on Someone Your Own Size I (m4n)
35.0% - Valigarmastered (EX1)
30.9% - Everkept (EX2)
20.1% - Savage Someone Your Own Size I (m4s)

So yes, they are the midcore content. You can safely assume that all the people who cleared m4s also cleared both Extremes for the weapon and accessories, leaving 10-15% of the player base as midcore. Which is quite a good estimate.

[ZoReee]

According to lalachievements:

53.1% - Pick on Someone Your Own Size I (m4n)
35.0% - Valigarmastered (EX1)
30.9% - Everkept (EX2)
20.1% - Savage Someone Your Own Size I (m4s)

So yes, they are the midcore content. You can safely assume that all the people who cleared m4s also cleared both Extremes for the weapon and accessories, leaving 10-15% of the player base as midcore. Which is quite a good estimate.

Seems like there's a discrepancy between ffxivcollect and lalaachievements, but you chose to be disingenuous instead of saying that(its probably because it only records the achievements of people who signed their account into it as it only tracks 220k people). Not to mention its well known not even 10% of the population participates in savages or higher so idk where they're getting 20%??? the average savage clear % of players is between 5-10% on new tiers

Also even if the numbers you chose are the ideal perfect numbers its a massive difference between 53% and 33% average Ex. Anyone looking at that would say its very clear how much harder one is over the other when you're essentially saying 53% = about 25% (if we count m1s which is probably completed at that rate per your numbers)


also under your numbers(lalaachievements) expert dungeons are cleared at the same exact rate of normal raids

Mapping the Realm: Alexandria
Discover every location within Alexandria.
10 60.0%

Mapping the Realm: Tender Valley
Discover every location within Tender Valley.
10 55.7%

Mapping the Realm: The Strayborough Deadwalk
Discover every location within the Strayborough Deadwalk. 10
55.4%

also here's the last alliance raid of endwalker

Mapping the Realm: Thaleia
Discover every location within Thaleia. 10 60.2%

[ZoReee]

According to lalachievements:

53.1% - Pick on Someone Your Own Size I (m4n)
35.0% - Valigarmastered (EX1)
30.9% - Everkept (EX2)
20.1% - Savage Someone Your Own Size I (m4s)

So yes, they are the midcore content. You can safely assume that all the people who cleared m4s also cleared both Extremes for the weapon and accessories, leaving 10-15% of the player base as midcore. Which is quite a good estimate.

I searched for an even better definition of hardcore content

"Hardcore is when clearing with new players is almost never going to happen before lockout, unless they're all of a decent skill level." - I think that's insanely fair and doesn't play lets dig into the achievement clearing numbers of random websites.

but in reality, the true midcore content is the content that doesn't exist between Normal Raids and Extremes. Nothing bridges a single wipe normal raid that you clear even your first time doing it vs getting locked out in EX. The jump up is too clear to say EX is midcore unless people want to define midcore as only ex,unreal, and M1s,M2s, while everything underneath that is casual and everything above that is hardcore, which i just don't agree with.

[AllenThyl]

but you chose to be disingenuous

Next time you want to throw out the accusation of "disingenuous", make sure you are the first one in the conversation to state where you got your numbers from, instead of just plucking them out of thin are and pretending that the numbers themselves somehow make your point with no context.

also under your numbers(lalaachievements) expert dungeons are cleared at the same exact rate of normal raids

Completion rate of "In the Glow of a New Dawn" (DT MSQ): 59.9%.
In other words, basically the population that finished with DT MSQ (which is the most casual of content), went and also cleared the normal raids and the expert dungeons. They are no "midcore" content, they are the casual content.
Quite frankly, this whole discussion with you makes me think that you just hope to not get grouped with the "casuals", who are often unfairly receiving unjustified flak. So you frantically try to reclassify easy and "casual" content as "midcore", because YOU PERSONALLY only manage to clear this easy content. If people aren't comfortable for whatever reason to go into the more difficult, that is perfectly fine. The easier stuff like dungeons, hunts and FATEs exist to serve as grind for mounts / minions / glams. But don't go around as if you have a solid grasp on the player skill level or the difficulty of content you have never seen from the inside.

I searched for an even better definition of hardcore content

"Hardcore is when clearing with new players is almost never going to happen before lockout, unless they're all of a decent skill level." - I think that's insanely fair and doesn't play lets dig into the achievement clearing numbers of random websites.

Cool. So "casual" content in the same vein is when basically guaranteed clearing with new players in a lockout, even if they aren't really of decent skill level. Because that applies to all the content you listed as "midcore". Dungeons, normal raids, alliance raids, field operaions, they are all "cleared" within a lockout. In case of Bozja, failing a fate / CE means nothing except lowered reward and maybe a bit of mettle loss. People just soldier on to the next fate / CE, since there is no real failure state. The instance doesn't evaporate and deletes people's characters.

Feel free to advocate for more of the casual content you enjoy, that's perfectly fine. But don't pretend that it isn't just mindless and low-skill stuff.