What to manage as a tank?

[CKNovel]

Yes and your point of reference is “if you nerfed WAR to DRK then there is still something wrong”. Is there though? That sounds like a fantastic solution to me, I’d love all the tanks to have about as much sustain as DRK, that’s like an optimal solution.

Thank you for confirming you don't want to just nerf Bloodwhetting, you want all tank forms of sustain gutted down to DRK level.
So you want tanks to feel as miserable as DRK and Healers.

As I've said, that's crab mentality, to pull others down to your unfun state.

My solutions allows to keep Bloodwhetting as it is while making Healers even more important and opening the door to more job identity and fun utility.
Yours close those door and wants everyone else to do nothing more than their main roles, just for the sake of some healer ego that wants the tank to die if they don't have a healer.
On top of that, healers would just heal the tank, not the party as a whole, which is paradoxal to what you wish for.