Fine, Bloodwhetting is too OP

[CKNovel]

I can recall what people said on this forum ten years ago. Don't worry, you're not the only one. But I'll be reading your words back to you every single time that you make a 'confident' contradiction. Judging from the trends around the length of expansions, I expect we'll get a good three years or so out of this quote.

But it's not really a competition between roles. If your goal was to absolutely push the limits of DPS optimisation, you'd be maining an actual DPS job. That's just common sense. It's good to broaden your experiences, but at the end of the day there's always an opportunity cost involved with how you invest your time.

"I won't do it because I don't want to invest time."
But you have the time and energy to remember what people say on this pointless forum 10 years ago?

If you rely on ad hominem instead of hard facts and experience, your arguments lack a foundation.
Beyond your opinion you've exposed no facts that can contradict anything.

Opinions aren't facts. I don't want to run in circle again because you have confidence in your missplaced opinion.

As for mitigation, it's fine. What we have currently with physical/magical split is better as we just brainlessly used them on every raidwide. It's good that for once, they're not the same used everywhere.
If you want "something else" it's the game that requires more combat mechanics. As long as XIV remains a number game where only damage and HP matters, we'll always run to the same problem.