Quote Originally Posted by Midare View Post
Sometimes I forget some people gets their dopamine shots by trying to appear morally better than others online, and each time I'm reminded, I can't help but to roll my eyes.

But putting that aside for a moment, there's some questions that has been on my mind for a while and, to add context to the thoughts, I'll bring back the VA's tweet that has been shown before:



She recognizes her shortcomings by saying that exertion sounds not in their assigned gender are difficult.

Could it be that gender has nothing with said limitations and there's something in a more innate level?

Can doctors magically deny basic intrinsic capabilities such as tonal range when they observe something when a human being is born?

I guess it's also phobic to point those limitations? Where does that put the VA herself?
My only response to this, is that as discussed in this thread there have been successful voice actors who have taken on roles of the opposite gender and had great performances.

I'd hate to generalize Sena's limited range to all trans actors, some of whom may have a larger range than Sena. There are also many CIS actors who have limited range and can't handle yelling or certain voice ranges.

I think range should be part of the audition process if it's needed for the role. For Wuk Lamat, which has scenes of yelling, delivering speeches from a balcony requiring a projected voice, and extreme emotional anguish - range is important and needed to be tested at the audition phase.