Quote Originally Posted by Turtledeluxe View Post
It would not be okay Ish. It would be the lowest rated and worst expansion as it is currently.

In my personal opinion, it's also cringe the way people talk about the character as though she is real. She is not. She is a poorly written character amongst many other poorly written things in DT. Maybe that's what people are trying to say in some of the rants I've seen.

I'm also not calling for anyone to stop talking. I am telling you that devs tend to interpret feedback a certain way and if what they garner from the expansion is "I hate Wuk Lamat" then we just won't see her again. The problem is, the odds you would see her again anyway are 0.005%. You can still continue to hate on a character that is not real, be my guest.

I would also note you're not even being objective. When you say "Wuk Lamat is the most inconsistent." Based on what metric? Every Scion we know acts out of character at some point and even new ones, like Bakool ja ja become unrecognizable once converted from cartoonist evil to good.

You are positing things like "if wuk lamat didn't exist, Krile's story would be well written." That is a contradiction considering this writer wrote this MSQ. They wrote Wuk Lamat. A lot of these arguments are copium.
I have no idea why you harp so much on fictional characters not being real. It's cringe. We know they are fictional characters, written by writers. No one thinks she's a real person. People criticize fictional characters, there are entire college courses on literary criticism, there are entire academic books on various fictional characters in Shakespeare plays. Fictional characters not being real is a given.

You can like or be fine with a writers work in some areas and have specific problem areas. I like Koana and Sphene, for example. But Wuk is another story. She was written so terribly, acted by a bad voice actor, and thrown in our faces for the entire MSQ we are sending the message we don't want to see this character again, or anyone else with her archetype or approach. I don't even want them to attempt writing more of her to try to redeem how utterly irritating she was to me.

Since I feel you need someone to state the obvious, this of course is all my opinion.