The artificial Eye reflection looks bad.

[Astronis]

I just booted up the benchmark again to check and it doesn't look like there are any permanent catchlights. Some of them only move around when you adjust the camera vertically, maybe that's what you're seeing?

Either way, I think the new catchlights look awful. In the previous benchmark they were there but subtle. Now it looks like I have a solar system rotating in my eyeball.

They're 'permanent' in that they're lights attached to the camera, so you'll always see them if you point the camera directly at your eyes. I quite liked them in the first benchmark too, but the subtlety seemed to have caused quite a stir.