Results -9 to 0 of 112

Threaded View

  1. #19
    Player
    Lady_Silvermoon's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2023
    Posts
    416
    Character
    Kasari Silvermoon
    World
    Seraph
    Main Class
    Machinist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Cleretic View Post
    Honestly, I think they already did. Going by their post history, I don't expect them to come back; they seem the type to really want to post about one subject, and then leave once they have.

    It was really frustrating to watch, because they had that awful mix of 'frequently factually incorrect' and 'grossly emotionally charged language'. I wanted to 'well actually' them a whole lot more than I have (Including with EE3 evidence, I was actually excited to bring that in), but for a lot of it they're clearly wrapping way too much of themselves and their own values into it, and they'd take it as a personal attack if I told them that actually, Emet would not be praised as the ender of poverty and sexual assault if he completed all the Rejoinings. I only really felt confident refuting the more isolated points, like a misunderstanding of how time travel works.

    I do kind of wonder why they did all this, because it really feels completely out of nowhere. Their post history confirms they're not the sort to do this regularly, and they completed Endwalker at least half a year ago (and were talking about very different parts of it), so this isn't 'I just hit the credits and I have kneejerk opinions'. It's also not just a new member/sockpuppet of the usual Team Zodiark crowd, because they tend to post together, and have fairly consistent talking points that this doesn't really jive with.
    You can see that much information on me? That's creepy. (My bad, I thought you could actually see my gameplay history, not that you guessed I finished Endwalker around my first posts.)

    To answer your question, I googled something that landed me on a forum thread and I sat there reading through 60 pages of a lore discussion from like two years ago, but didn't want to comment on it because it was like two years ago. So after reading that, I looked up some more current posts. Wrote some comments, went to bed and woke up to my existence being highly analyzed and discussed in a way I'm not used to seeing on forums. But okay.

    Just a rando who usually discusses lore on other mediums and just happened upon a forum post last night. That's all.
    (7)
    Last edited by Lady_Silvermoon; 01-03-2024 at 11:05 AM.