Quote Originally Posted by SoupHali View Post
There’s already a mechanism that recognizes if someone in the party hasn’t cleared the fight. If there’s a first time bonus - lower the max ilvl and grant bonus exp. Otherwise leave it as is. Roulettes aren’t just there for new people, they’re also for people who want the daily exp boost as quickly as possible. If there’s nobody new to the fight there’s no point making it longer/more annoying to complete.
That's where you are wrong though. Roulettes exist solely to make sure old content is filled with enough people for new players to go through it smoothly. The experience and tomes that you get are just the bait that is being used to lure old players in to help out. Besides, we are talking about trials. Even if the max ilvl is lowered it wont make it into some long and arduous experience. It will maybe add 2 or 3 minutes on to the fight. If you are there for the rewards alone then that's really not much, but it can absolutely make the difference between a good experience and a bad one for new players.