Enmity Management, Do we want it back?

[Zairava]

I personally want it back, but I don't think they'll ever revert it or try to think of a way to implement it better than it was (which would honestly just be buffing the enmity generation from tank stance so that the dps wouldn't need to use diversion/old lucid). They perhaps thought of that is my guess, but they ultimately decided on just making it impossible to fall off after a few GCD's.

[Marxam]

I personally want it back, but I don't think they'll ever revert it or try to think of a way to implement it better than it was (which would honestly just be buffing the enmity generation from tank stance so that the dps wouldn't need to use diversion/old lucid). They perhaps thought of that is my guess, but they ultimately decided on just making it impossible to fall off after a few GCD's.

Tanks are getting a lvl 1 trait in 7.0 where they will always have enmity regardless of stance and their stance acts only as a job gauge similar to DPS and is not tied to any enmity generation. They are also reducing the timers of shirk to 60 secs. Please look forward to it.

[ForteNightshade]

I personally want it back, but I don't think they'll ever revert it or try to think of a way to implement it better than it was (which would honestly just be buffing the enmity generation from tank stance so that the dps wouldn't need to use diversion/old lucid). They perhaps thought of that is my guess, but they ultimately decided on just making it impossible to fall off after a few GCD's.

This would only reinforce the exact system that existed before: pull with Defiance, press Unchained and swap to Deliverance either after Main/Storm's Eye. Tanks proceed to voke/shirk periodically so they never have to turn on tank stance again.

Too many people have revisionist history when it comes to aggro. Tanks weren't stance dancing or really considering aggro whatsoever unless a DPS didn't press Division. In which case, they'd often let said DPS eat autos until Unchained or Shirk were off CD. If that system existed nowadays, tanks would sooner toss Nascent/HoC/TBN/Intervention on a DPS than switch to tank stance. The whole reason we have the system we do now is because tanks weren't ever going into tank stance anyway. So what's the point?