Tank Stance/Shirk - Get rid of it.

[Ransu]

It's like people can't read. Shirk has a long recast. Shorten it and off tanks can just drop aggro faster. I have done end game raid, and still thought the same thing. Old tank stance made much more sense when it affected you with defense buff/attack down, versus attack up/ def down.
SquareEnix got rid of "stances" because low skill players couldn't manage it well. I'm just encourage the simplifications further. I actually enjoying the skill with switching stances...old style.

Instead of a simple tank stance you're essentially placing shirk and provoke into a rotation which just creates a headache for both tanks because both will be constantly creating equal threat and will need to deal with it by spamming voke and shirk making tank swaps a massive chore. Forget statics.... God help the pug groups with two tanks fighting even more over who is the main tank.

[Absurdity]

Instead of a simple tank stance you're essentially placing shirk and provoke into a rotation which just creates a headache for both tanks because both will be constantly creating equal threat and will need to deal with it by spamming voke and shirk making tank swaps a massive chore. Forget statics.... God help the pug groups with two tanks fighting even more over who is the main tank.

The other issue is what if you simply deal significantly more damage than your co-tank to the point that you creep up on their enmity even after a voke+shirk tank swap?

Because I've had that happen in savage before but I could simply drop my tank stance for a while to make it a non-issue. I most certainly don't want a scenario where I simply die because I don't have any tools as a tank to manage my own threat outside of the occasional shirk.

[Noox-115]

Unpopular opinion : I would like Tanks to have an Enmity Generation combo like they used to. I know it will sound dumb for a lot of people but I always love to have more combos to spice the fight a bit more beside it would split tanks and blue dps. But sadly they wanna make the game easy for everyone truly a shame.

[SerophisRagnarok]

okay then by this logic we need to also get rid of Summoning carbie/fairy, Kardia, Dance Partner, etc. just hit the button dude. jeez.

[Mikey_R]

okay then by this logic we need to also get rid of Summoning carbie/fairy, Kardia, Dance Partner, etc. just hit the button dude. jeez.

I have no idea what this is even in response to, you are going to need to clarify.

As for the next post about syncing, technically, the lowest is level 10 in the Guildhest roulette, however, since it uses the same system for syncing down in FATEs, and you can sync below level 10 in them, it makes sense. Behind the scenes, it doesn't just reduce your level, it actually gets rid of all buffs, then syncs you down, this is likely to prevent any sort of bugs or glitches where players have buffs that they shouldn't have at the new level.