Quote Originally Posted by Renathras View Post
Oh no, it's not talking about AST.

It's saying "Suppose we gave SGE a BLM level rotation and it healed with just oGCDs and Kardia. But also did the same damage and healing of WHM. Many players would play it (because they want more DPS rotation), but then complain that they aren't being rewarded with a higher output.

I think SE just doesn't want to deal with that.



No, that question wouldn't "have perspective".

...which is why that wasn't the question asked. Drop the hyperbole, please.

"BUT THIS IS WHAT DPS JOB ROTATION MEANS!!!"

No, DPS Job rotation means what I said above, 8+ abilities related to damage, with a timing and sequence they must be used in to do good damage. You REALLY need to stop approaching anything anyone opposed to you says with "What's the WORST possible way I can interpret this..."

EDIT:



Have you only posted these here, or also on Reddit?

Also, how do these compare to other role results so far?
I do not understand how anyone would interpret “having a rotation on the level of a DPS job” as only 8 actions. That’s what tanks have, DPS have significantly more.

And several responders on that thread also pointed out how unrealistic that was because of the action total, so clearly the wording of that question is misleading.

Someone else posted a link of that thread on Reddit before I did. They just posted the link to the official forum thread where I put those surveys though.

The other jobs are also getting responses. Paladin, Dark Knight and Summoner have about as many responses as Sage, like 14-18 responses so far. Other jobs have less. I’m on my phone so I don’t have an easy way to share specifics. Paladins mostly split between 1s and 7s on the rework, but is overall probably in the 6-8/10 range on ratings. Summoner is probably around a 6-7/10 on its scores roughly, a few 9s/10s but a lot that are between 1-6. Around 42% say EW is the best Summoner, but the other 58% is split evenly between SB and ShB. Dark Knight is probably closer to 7-8 on its scores, and it seems more positive, but around 88% prefer HW and SB Dark Knight. Darks arts is referenced in the comments a lot as needing to return.