What's the point with that quite lackluster story in Endwalker?

[Absimiliard]

Its because just like how you guys feel that EW's story wasnt that good despite its praise, I feel the same way with Shadowbringer's msq (and Heavensward to that extent) where everyone and their mom overly praise it yet Im like the only person who didnt felt like it was this masterpiece of a narrative.

I wouldn't say only one. I was down with a lot of it, but it really lost me on that last patch. For that to be how the expansion ended... well, let's just say it kinda soured the entire thing in my eyes. It had plenty of questionable bits beforehand as well, but I was able to look past them until that. I mean dude, Elidibus suddenly went from big brain to DERP SMASH, AM SUDOKU BY COP for no discernible reason, and Emet-Selch somehow went from being devoted to his people to just, "yeah, cool, I'll free you from the void so you can kill off the last hope of my people." The things we found out in Endwalker only served to exacerbate my already intense dislike of ShB's final patch.