Quote Originally Posted by Gemina View Post
I definitely like how WHM brings damage. I am also predicting they will get Misery II next expansion, which will incentivize lily usage even more. Along with that, I am hoping they update the lily gauge to allow the WHM to earn lilies, along with getting them passively. I think they could work it where if the WHM does not perform an action that earns them a lily within 30s, then they get one anyway. And if they do earn one, the 30s timer resets.

I believe every healer's gauge should award them via damage to the enemy like Misery. That being said, I have no idea why Macrocosmos is not tied to the AST seals. I need to play SGE more, but SCH is interesting in this regard. Their gauge needs to be looked at for sure because it is tied to a very niche ability; however, this niche ability has the potential to increase their DPS window. I understand that this is a very unfulfilling approach to contributing to dmg as a healer, but it is still very effective nonetheless. I also understand that interactive gauges like AST cards increase APM, and increasing/decreasing APM can really impact how a job plays and feels.

I need to play SGE more, but I honestly don't know what to give SCH. I know this echoes the devs and sounds crazy. Don't tar and feather me though, I just think it would feel weird at this point as SCH has more or less been the same since the beginning of ShB. I don't object to getting another dmg skill though. I just don't care to get back old skills like Bane and Miasma. I would rather get something new. Something very fitting for a SCH. Misery blooms into a flower and explodes. Macrocosmos rains comets. These are very fitting for WHM and AST respectively. I'm just not sure what. Something involving Lily. I know that.
I don’t know if I want to get into another lore argument but why don’t you want bane or miasma back for SCH, that is SCH’s lore, SCH isn’t a pretty job, it’s a tactician/field medic

This trend towards “fey mage” has no basis in SCH’s lore and makes it feel too much like a WHM

I would be happy just with shadowflare back for some interesting interaction with sacred soil