So, you participate in duties with the "J" flagged? Or do you participate in duties with the "E" flagged? It makes a difference in the players you'll meet.
I play with EDF selected, (mainly because D/F are like 1/million chance on elemental), the only time ill ever put J on is for normal dungeons or roulettes, or older EX trials where communication is not needed.
Saying an entire nation would not make an insulting remark is equally as ridiculous as saying someone is stupid for being a foreigner.
Why is it so hard for people to grasp that rude/racist/whatever people exist REGARDLESS of race? Just because someone is japanese, doesn’t automatically make turn them into completely perfect members of society. Yes the tendency in Japan is to be polite more so than anywhere else, BUT exceptions to the rule do exist no matter the country.
Its beyond me how ignorant someone must be to believe an entire nation behaves like factory made robots with the same thought process inputs.
We can never know if OPs post is real or not, therefore you cant make it a statement that it isn’t .
TBH nowadays I just assume every person that starts a thread like this one is just playing the "I'm and victim" card while hiding what they actually did to irritate, troll, or anger the other people in their story in game simply because an overwhelming majority of the time that ends up being the case. It's basically become one of the basic routines in the "Karen" handbook...I still find it very hard to believe the story about comment that you say was made, one bad experience shouldn't have made you make this post.
Next time look on PF is 100's of day 1 blind progs set up. Its an unwritten rule what I keep saying about DF, and yet you refuse to acknowledge this is the case on our servers.
IF it did happen it sucks, sorry it happened, let it go and move on!
As a foreigner in Japan I'd say that JP are not quite racist, but closer to elitist. They don't really care about your color or religion or stuff as long as you can speak their language, basically their standard is "JP speaker" and "everyone else". You see "native speaker only" on Elemental PF a lot but if you speak(type, to be precise) the language well enough they actually wouldn't care. Their super closed society kinda makes them rather...inconsiderate? towards racism-related topics/wordings, so I think that's what making them actually look racist.
That said, so far I know whenever they be toxic to English speakers, I don't think they use the term "stupid foreigner". They do use the term "go home" when they want ppl to go away, but judging from your story, I imagine the 7 ppl left you out of the loop while talking about kicking you out of the party, it kinda feels unnatural they'd say "go home" directly to you when they're not even talking to you. "Stupid foreigner" is... idk, it sounds alien to me. like, baka gaijin? never heard ppl saying that before aside from 2chan.
(btw I'm not saying that you're lying, I'm just wondering the chance that your translation tool isn't working accurately)
I have the same thought. I live in Japan as well (and fully fluent in the language), and I really can't imagine what phrase / word would translate to "stupid foreigner."
That is why I asked in the 3rd page of this thread the exact term that was used. This can be a mis-understanding unless the OP is also fluent, and god forbid if google translate or something equally inaccurate was used.
Isn't it "baka gaijin"?I have the same thought. I live in Japan as well (and fully fluent in the language), and I really can't imagine what phrase / word would translate to "stupid foreigner."
That is why I asked in the 3rd page of this thread the exact term that was used. This can be a mis-understanding unless the OP is also fluent, and god forbid if google translate or something equally inaccurate was used.
Mortal Fist
Nobody really says that here though. They might call you Baka, but I can’t really say I’ve heard “Baka gaijin” said maliciously. It’s less about you being a foreigner and more about you being ignorant/illiterate.
Come to think of it, I don’t think anyone actually calls anyone Baka when they are really angry… it’s like…cliche romance anime nonsense.
…and I can’t remember even being called gaijin to my face before… I think at worst I’ve had friends say “sasuga Amerikajin da ne!” at some dumb thing I did. (Translate: “That’s an American for ya, lol”)
Last edited by kaynide; 08-26-2022 at 07:12 PM.
That's not what we mean (the ones disputing the translation). Of course it's possible that somebody would type insulting things while JP or using the JP client. The problem is that the specific things they said don't sound plausible. Some of the most cutting, insulting things a JP-speaker can say would machine-translate to be very benign-sounding in English, while the things OP translated in their post are atypically confrontational, given the structure of the language and culture. I have definitely heard JP people (IRL) insulting foreigners before but I have literally never heard anybody, in a game environment, say "go home" in Japanese with it having the exact same nuance it does in EN - and if they've learned that from EN players they would probably type it in EN. I am 99% sure that in this case they were telling OP to leave the party and she misunderstood because she couldn't contemplate why anybody would be displeased by a griefer using their farm party as a learning group and ignoring advice each time they wiped.
I don't know how different it is on Tonberry, which has a higher proportion of non-speakers, but if you don't flag J in DF your queue it will basically never pop, so I'm genuinely surprised that OP claims that she never flags J for learning but gets into all of these parties trying to farm content they've already learned in PF. If that's really true I doubt that the party she was in was even entirely JP players, very few of whom flag E because it's so hard to communicate in tight situations unless they're genuinely fluent. So if all of this is true - which I still strongly, strongly doubt - a report against the problem player would have been the appropriate action.
That's not what you might mean, but the person SassyAssassin is replying to is literally saying that "Japanese players would not in public chat say stupid foreigner, it would not happen," which is just not true. To say that all Japanese players wouldn't say something offensive like this is a ridiculous blanket statement.
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.