Is the "healing portion" of healers hitting a wall in EW?

[Semirhage]

As for your suggestion list etc, I know it wasn't written with myself or this conversation in mind. For the substance, I'll be completely forthcoming - you lost me at "add back Miasma" and you especially lost me at "make bane yet another dot on top of that." I've made my opinions on multi-dotting relatively clear. I most assuredly, 100%, am not playing a healer to play a miniature version of an affliction warlock, absolutely not. The class concept you have presented is something I wouldn't touch with a 11 foot pole. Again, it's nothing personal or intended as a slight against you in any way, just can't stress enough how much the idea of ever managing multiple dots again chafes at me the wrong way.

Heavens to Betsy, anything but managing more than 1111111111111! Anything more complex than that would just make healers plain unplayable.

Healers were nerfed down into being the most boring jobs I've ever seen in an MMO because this game's Sylphie population bellyached and whined and moaned that doing more than casting one spell a gajillion times over and over again in content was "too haaaaaaaaaaard" and appearing incompetent made them feel bad, so they screamed to remove the ability to become competent rather than actually practicing and becoming competent; hence the healing part became easy, and the downtime kits became easy, because the people who refused to countenance more than easymode got their way. It wasn't because "evil DPS healers" argued to "become more powerful" and ended up shooting themselves in the foot or whatever. I've been complaining about the downward spiral in healer engagement since late Heavensward. Because my main job got handed over to its Sylphie population on a silver platter, and it's been moving in that direction ever since.

And being DPS mains who share that Sylphie opinion on how healers "should" play, the devs went along with it.

[Katoar]

Heavens to Betsy, anything but managing more than 1111111111111! Anything more complex than that would just make healers plain unplayable.

Healers were nerfed down into being the most boring jobs I've ever seen in an MMO because this game's Sylphie population bellyached and whined and moaned that doing more than casting one spell a gajillion times over and over again in content was "too haaaaaaaaaaard" and appearing incompetent made them feel bad, so they screamed to remove the ability to become competent rather than actually practicing and becoming competent; hence the healing part became easy, and the downtime kits became easy, because the people who refused to countenance more than easymode got their way. It wasn't because "evil DPS healers" argued to "become more powerful" and ended up shooting themselves in the foot or whatever. I've been complaining about the downward spiral in healer engagement since late Heavensward. Because my main job got handed over to its Sylphie population on a silver platter, and it's been moving in that direction ever since.

And being DPS mains who share that Sylphie opinion on how healers "should" play, the devs went along with it.

Healers have more to manage than a single button though. We DPS most of the time but you still need to heal with oGCDs.

[Silver-Strider]

Healers have more to manage than a single button though. We DPS most of the time but you still need to heal with oGCDs.

That's literally no different to any other role using their oGCD skills between their rotations.
It's like saying that Tanks can't have more than 1 button because they need to manage their mitigation CDs.
If a WAR is able to manage their rotation and keep a party of 3 DPS alive with the small handful of oGCDs they have that heal/shield party members, there is literally no reason the same courtesy can't be extended to healers.

[Katoar]

That's literally no different to any other role using their oGCD skills between their rotations.
It's like saying that Tanks can't have more than 1 button because they need to manage their mitigation CDs.
If a WAR is able to manage their rotation and keep a party of 3 DPS alive with the small handful of oGCDs they have that heal/shield party members, there is literally no reason the same courtesy can't be extended to healers.

I am not saying that healers should have only one button for DPS. My point is that we have other things to manage besides our Nuke and DoT.

[Silver-Strider]

I am not saying that healers should have only one button for DPS. My point is that we have other things to manage besides our Nuke and DoT.

What healers have to manage is a shadow of the past

We had multiple DoTs
We had shields to apply or party members would die.
We had Virus/Disable to debuffs enemies
We had Fairies to swap between
We had cards to extend the duration of, spread to everyone, etc.
We had Aggro and MP to manage

What we have now is even less to manage than what we did in ARR, if you can even call it "managing". It feels more like SE pandering a child than actually respecting our intelligence.

[Sebazy]

I am not saying that healers should have only one button for DPS. My point is that we have other things to manage besides our Nuke and DoT.

*In content that actually needs a credible amount of healing

You can fumble your way through a surprising amount of the game with medica II alone, no need to manage anything then! =(

I wonder if making healers more complex would reduce the amount of healers. I know that if I suddenly had to start pressing more buttons to do the exact same thing, I would be rethinking if I enjoyed that thing. imo of course, I'm not a healer, so I can't judge.

Note that healer queues for just about any roulette are generally instant these days and have been for a while now.

Now look back to Heavensward when healing was generally more challenging and actually had a proper skill ceiling to boot. Yet there were comparatively more healers queueing for roulettes because healer queues generally weren't instant.

Sure, healing is accessible, more so than it's ever been. But ffs please understand that once you have some kind of understanding of what's going on and your kit, mainstream content like Aglaia is just beyond boring especially if you don't get a complete clown shower for a raid. ~30 minutes of pressing the same button over and over and over again. I stopped going as healer because Nald scales wipes had me struggling to pick up the willpower to get up off the floor.