Third party tools are a game design failing in a multi-platform game

[Ralphe2449]

Yes, you can learn basic rotation from the game, but an optimized rotation you cannot learn from the tools the game gives you. The game also doesn't give you any feedback on areas where you may have made mistakes while focusing on mechanics, which in turn means that you do not know what you need to work on to improve.

Unless there's hidden interactions the optimized rotations is more often than not obvious.

Now if you are referring on tailoring said rotation to the encounter's mechanic that is also quite clear, when you waste a combo or a cd offensive or mobility due to a mechanic the mistake is blatant and now you know what you should do next time. Unless you want to argue people dont pay attention to their buffs/dots and just brainlessly spam 1,2,3 irrespective of how many times the mechanic screws theirrotation. Maximizing uptime is also quite obvious, when you fail to do that you know that next time you need to do something different to maximize it.

You dont need the game to tell you "Hey, maybe if you hadnt wasted your cd early and lost seconds of it you would have maximized its efficiency" (obviously depending on encounter duration)