Paladin weakest Tank now

[DanielNegreanu_Adamantoise]

Despite opinions it's pick rate would flop, every dedicated tank raider will tell you this. Having more mitigations than other tanks isn't ever useful, it makes the Savage raids notably more difficult if it were to be lower DPS.

I don’t think so, warrior pick rate hasn’t flopped and it’s not up to par with drk/gnb
Warrior is max comfy and let’s healer not worry about them
If pld were to truly, actually, become a tank that does on par damage with warrior while also being warrior levels of comfy it would have a much better pick rate
Why I’m abandoning pld for warrior is because, warrior ALSO supports the group better. Yeah nascent is max comfy and better group support

“But clemency is better in those 5% of scenarios”
^
You even ask paladins about something better than clemency and they are attached to the very thing that holds them back. It doesn’t matter that nascent and shake it off prevents most of those 5% scenarios from happening in the first place. It doesn’t matter that warrior never needed to spam clemency on self to finish off a boss.
They just remember those 5% scenarios where clemency was clutch, even if you could reduce those scenarios to 1%…

As it stands I don’t see it changing. Warrior IS the paladin I was looking for, so my problem is solved as soon as I get used to this new rotation

But imo until clemency is fundamentally changed/replaced pld will always be a shadow of what it was supposed to be