What's the point with that quite lackluster story in Endwalker?

[KizuyaKatogami]

snip

Considering she caused far more death than the ascians ever did, while also lying,manipulating,and keeping secrets not only from her own people but from us as well, yes to me she’s a villain. Had she actually told her people the truth, perhaps they could have banded together and prevented the final days from occurring in the first place. But no, instead she kept it a secret. You just keep creating double standards for the sundered where it’s okay for them to do something but wrong for the ancients to do so.The lykaons were also a case of doing it for the greater good as they were going to end up slaughtering the other specimans. Lets not forget btw, if you do diadem, one of the mounts even acknowledges the fact that the "adventurers"(our wol's) from old diadem rendered an entire species almost extinct with only one surviving.Great value on life that. The sundered didn’t exactly get the message, do you remember ironworks? They were willing to sacrifice an entire timeline of people to bring back the wol because they couldn’t move forward in their world. The ancients were planning to move forward though, their whole plan was to resume their duties after the 3rd sacrifice, Venat didn’t give them that chance. Zodiark is without a doubt a “good guy.” He shielded the planet for thousands of years and kept it safe. Were it not for him we would be dead. Elidibus sacrificed himself for us, without him, again, we would be dead.

[NanaWiloh]

The sticking point for me is Venat retaining her memories. This means that she purposefully waited for 75% of her brethren to sacrifice themselves before intervening (and suddenly being anti-sacrifice). It also means that she knowingly created more reflections than necessary to serve as fodder for the Ascians. As far as I'm concerned, those trillions of lives lost in rejoinings fall squarely at Venat's feet. There's been no indication that she's ever been able to or even interested in protecting the shards given that her contingency plan was to abandon them.

The Ascians also aren't responsible for every conflict ever among the sundered. It doesn't appear they had any hand in the Dragonsong War until the end where Lahabrea thought he might manipulate Thordan. We only know Emet was responsible for the origination of Allag and Garlemald, but once established those nations went on to do quite a bit of their own free will without Ascian guidance. It's too convenient to attribute all of mankind's sins onto the unsundered who were just exploiting weaknesses in the sundered.

As for sacrificing life on the Source, that would have been non-Amaurotine life. The whole point of the rejoinings is to make everyone whole again and to eventually release the souls within Zodiark, it'd be counterproductive to sacrifice the sundered.

She was not suddenly anti-sacrifice she opposed the idea of summoning Zodiark from the start. She had faith her people could stop Meteon without such drastic measures. Its funny but Gaius when we first meet him expressed his disgust over this very thing, mankind turning to higher provinces and gods for strength rather then relying on his own strength. Venat's choice to say nothing was poor but she accepted blame for all that happened. Her faith in mankind was finally rewarded in the end as we became strong enough to stop Meteon without her or Zordiark.

[KizuyaKatogami]

She was not suddenly anti-sacrifice she opposed the idea of summoning Zodiark from the start. She had faith her people could stop Meteon without such drastic measures. Its funny but Gaius when we first meet him expressed his disgust over this very thing, mankind turning to higher provinces and gods for strength rather then relying on his own strength. Venat's choice to say nothing was poor but she accepted blame for all that happened. Her faith in mankind was finally rewarded in the end as we became strong enough to stop Meteon without her or Zordiark.

Except for the fact we needed both her and Zodiark to get that strong in the first place, to say nothing of the fact Zenos needed to eat her crystal to even help us and we relied on her constructs and ship to get us to Ultima Thule. How were they expected to fight against meteion with no knowledge exactly? It took us leaping through major plot hurdles and time travel to even think about getting to her.

[BokoToloko]

C

You have literally zero metrics for deaths and pinpointing every death for age as a Hydaelyn kill is as absurd as proclaiming Amaurot culture is the culprit for their suicides. And not only that, the habitants themselves would have to admit it as abnormal which they don't. Not to mention it assumes the sundered lives follow Amaurotian standards when they DON'T. They're a whole different thing with a whole different set of values and yes, different standards for what living entails. And if people actually cursed that condition, then the Ascians would've had their work cut out for them. Just tell them their future selves will be better if they renounce themselves for the good ol' Zodiark. You count as a crime, but literally most (if not all) would see it as anything but that. The only ones who can't cope with that fact are the Ascians, who are completely unable to come to terms with it.

And Zodiark and their followers have NEVER been the good guys, and the fact people try to believe the subversion of expectatives work here is absolutely baffling. You go several expansion trying to fix the messes Ascians leave left and right, witnessing the atrocities they commit and just because they have lived in a cool place that bad bad crystal mommy took away from them they're completely justified and the life and work of the Warrior of Light is a pile of worthless misguided garbage they should've gotten rid of in favor to champaigning the glorious genocides and ruining the lives instead of improving them just because... Elidibus himself tried to killed us. Several times. And literally stripped other worlds from their heroes for the last stand, using them to fuel himself. But, hey, he saved us that one time, so it's all good.

And then I'm the one using double standard when you're using every fringe situation to illustrate a case that's focused on the MSQ and the MSQ alone. And I never said the sundered were good or better, but trying to paint the Ascians and Zodiark as good guys is as disingenuous as it gets. As a matter of fact, any attempt to reduce the plot to a black/white is absurd.

[Rulakir]

Also, Midgarsomr and Tiamat himselfs hint the possibility they had a hand in Dragonsong War starting in Azys Lla as they point them to be the root of the miseries. Not to mention, we see several instance of Ascian causing disgraces left and right, specially in ARR. Also, Garlean and Allag catastrophes were full within the Ascian plans and the Ascian themselves helped them to it (Dalamud is a pretty good reminder for both cases). Also, Emet-Selch is very explicit in saying "the remaining habitants of the Source". That really isn't open to any interpretation and it being "non-Amaurotian" REALLY doesn't soften the blow of, you know, commiting more genocide for their egotistical objectives.

The events in Meracydia aren't linked to the Dragonsong War. If you have evidence the Ascians were involved in telling Thordan I to slaughter Ratatoskr and devour her eyes or telling Nidhogg to enact 1k years' worth of revenge upon Ishgardians for it, then by all means.

It's not meant to soften the blow, it's meant to clarify. I'll also say again, rejoinings wouldn't have been a thing without the sundering in the first place.

She was not suddenly anti-sacrifice she opposed the idea of summoning Zodiark from the start.

I'm going to need a source for this because Venat had no plan that didn't involve Zodiark's aetherial barrier buying them time.

Her faith in mankind was finally rewarded in the end as we became strong enough to stop Meteon without her or Zordiark.

Ah, no. The day was barely won by the WoL who had been groomed for it from the start and given every tool past, present, and future to ensure success, which included the assistance of the unsundered. (Noting that were it not for Emet's sentimentality he would've likely killed the WoL on the spot on the First, so the WoL also had to be a reincarnated Azem for this to play out as well.) Mankind without the WoL and their links to the unsundered absolutely fails to defeat Meteion.

[NanaWiloh]

Except for the fact we needed both her and Zodiark to get that strong in the first place, to say nothing of the fact Zenos needed to eat her crystal to even help us and we relied on her constructs and ship to get us to Ultima Thule. How were they expected to fight against meteion with no knowledge exactly? It took us leaping through major plot hurdles and time travel to even think about getting to her.

No denying they put us on the right course. Their gone now and its our job to hold the course or perish like those before.

[BokoToloko]

The events in Meracydia aren't linked to the Dragonsong War. If you have evidence the Ascians were involved in telling Thordan I to slaughter Ratatoskr and devour her eyes or telling Nidhogg to enact 1k years' worth of revenge upon Ishgardians for it, then by all means.

It's not meant to soften the blow, it's meant to clarify. I'll also say again, rejoinings wouldn't have been a thing without the sundering in the first place.

It's pretty hard to prove direct link between Ascians because they make sure to not leave marks in history. Also, the rejoining wouldn't have happened if the Ascians had accepted their world was over or actually tried to do the same, WoL, do, try to improve their lives instead. They're the culprits and the ones responsible for the rejoinings in the same way Venat is responsible for the sundering.

Ah, no. The day was barely won by the WoL who had been groomed for it from the start and given every tool past, present, and future to ensure success, which included the assistance of the unsundered. (Noting that were it not for Emet's sentimentality he would've likely killed the WoL on the spot on the First, so the WoL also had to be a reincarnated Azem for this to play out as well.) Mankind without the WoL and their links to the unsundered absolutely fails to defeat Meteion.

Links Venat had accounted for (she was the one who carried Emet to the aetherial sea). And most of the struggle to fight Meteion would've failed if mankind as a whole hadn't supported WoL in any stage, such as refined adamantite and the Garlean contingent. The entire point of the story is ultimately: Help the world get their shit together and see how your deeds carry over. Everyone contributed. It's absurd to overthink the classic trope of the hero being supported by those he saved.

[Lauront]

If we spun a narrative whereby the sundered had to see themselves sundered again right after some cataclysmic event, to the degree that they no longer exist as they do now, but morph into entirely different beings, perhaps with shorter lifespans, much smaller forms and no magic for starters, it'd be interesting to see if their reaction would be just to embrace whatever rationale the would-be sunderer puts forward - if they elect to put it forward and don't just spring it upon them after offering platitudes - and then are told to just roll with it, do nothing to rectify the situation as the star is shattered even further - whoops, maybe several times more than is necessary for the sunderer's supposed Noble Goal (tm). To further comfort the sundered-sundered, we could tell them it's not "really" a genocide, because look, there's more of them (albeit in a form unrecognisable to them), and hey, their lifespans were cut drastically, but they didn't die on the spot...just when that reduced lifespan expired! A situation in which, for example, Alisaie has already admitted she'd do much the same as the Ascians. I somehow doubt they'd just roll over with this in pursuit of "moving on" and embracing some alleged "brighter tomorrow." I certainly would not. That aside, if they would not, then it is entirely understandable why the unsundered Ascians would not, either.

There is no proof as such of the Ascians being involved in the Dragonsong War's instigation, because that came down to the verdict Nidhogg had passed on mankind as inadequate as stewards of the star (his role was that of protector of his kin) and Thordan and his lackeys realisation of the power held in the dragons' eyes. None of this requires Ascian instigation and indeed, is consistent with the fate of the dragons who fled the Dragonstar and happened upon other stars, only to find themselves locked in conflict with the natives.

At the end of the day, the WoL succeeded only due to ample aid from beings such as the unsundered, dragons and the intercession of the Supreme Deity (i.e. actually providing the roadmap she withheld from her own people and more besides), plus Zodiark buffering the planet for lo these thousands of years. If we're going to try to play some "x are better" game, there is no "absurd over-thinking" involved here. It is highlighting facts inconvenient to that narrative, rather. Even the story is not really trying to justify it all so much as present a roadmap of how we got from there to here.

[Rulakir]

It's pretty hard to prove direct link between Ascians because they make sure to not leave marks in history.

Likewise, you can't attribute all the ills of the world to the Ascians. The sundered all on their own are capable of unimaginable cruelty as we've seen repeatedly starting as early as level 15 in ARR.

Also, the rejoining wouldn't have happened if the Ascians had accepted their world was over or actually tried to do the same, WoL, do, try to improve their lives instead. They're the culprits and the ones responsible for the rejoinings in the same way Venat is responsible for the sundering.

Words are easy. Fact of the matter is telling people who've survived a horrific apocalypse where their loved ones were forced against their will to conjure creatures of nightmare that devoured people in the streets, then had more loved ones volunteer to be trapped in indefinite purgatory within Zodiark just to make it stop, that in their moments of trauma and grief need to move on is incredibly tone deaf. Not to mention that returning to the star was a core and important part of their beliefs and those who'd sacrificed themselves to save the world were now prohibited from doing that.

Frankly, I think the game did a poor job of depicting how terrible the Final Days actually were (not helped by the fact that the return of them amounted to virtually nothing so the sundered never got a true appreciation of what the Ancients went through either). It's more like your loved ones are now POWs, but instead of trying to rescue them you should just forget them and move on with your life. No one would do that, especially when they had a means of bringing them back.

Venat didn't give the Ancients any context as to why they should change (not that it mattered because someone was always going to have to face and defeat Meteion, embracing suffering and despair wasn't going to make any difference in that regard). It was basically:

Ancient1: We have a plan to release those you lost.
Me: Great, do it!
Venat: No, don't!
Me: Why?
Venat: Because...! Reasons.
Me: Uh, that's not good enough, go ahead with the plan.
Venat: *sunder* That's what you get for not doing what I wanted!

Links Venat had accounted for (she was the one who carried Emet to the aetherial sea).

You're just reaffirming what I said.

[NanaWiloh]

The events in Meracydia aren't linked to the Dragonsong War. If you have evidence the Ascians were involved in telling Thordan I to slaughter Ratatoskr and devour her eyes or telling Nidhogg to enact 1k years' worth of revenge upon Ishgardians for it, then by all means.

It's not meant to soften the blow, it's meant to clarify. I'll also say again, rejoinings wouldn't have been a thing without the sundering in the first place.



I'm going to need a source for this because Venat had no plan that didn't involve Zodiark's aetherial barrier buying them time.



Ah, no. The day was barely won by the WoL who had been groomed for it from the start and given every tool past, present, and future to ensure success, which included the assistance of the unsundered. (Noting that were it not for Emet's sentimentality he would've likely killed the WoL on the spot on the First, so the WoL also had to be a reincarnated Azem for this to play out as well.) Mankind without the WoL and their links to the unsundered absolutely fails to defeat Meteion.

Yes..yes we had help. I forget this is the forum and even the obvious needs to pointed or peoples brains shut off. Thought it was common knowledge even heroes need help at times. Take no offense to this just a rant I have..

The ff14 Venat wiki covers Venat lore. It is also pointed out in game as well, but its back in shadowbringers. Somewhere in all the questing through Amourant. But she did oppose the summoning of zodiark do to the vast amount of lives that were required.