Paladin weakest Tank now

[Absimiliard]

You're missing the point. And the only thing that is expected out of anyone, is not dying.

As long as any dps-checks are being covered, it does not matter on the long run if a Tank does 4500 or 5100 damage on average (just a example), in the end, youre going to stick to the fight either way, even if someone isn't playing his optimal Rotation. As long as he doesn't die, all is good, and if you kick someone because of not providing optimal DPS, allow me to remind you that this can be considered as a valid reason to get you suspended.

Ah, the "the new TOS says dismissing people for poor gameplay is a bannable offense" argument. Well, that aside, you're going to want to take up your aversion to the notion of tanks being expected to pull their weight with almost the entire rest of the community. I haven't missed your point. I am telling you the general community's view on the subject. You are expected to do more than simply not die. Actively dragging a group down with poor DPS, regardless of your role, is unacceptable. The faster a boss dies, the less chance of something going wrong. So why wouldn't people want more than the bare minimum? Dragging it out just makes you more likely to wipe.