Please Tell Me If WHM is OKAY or Not

[Sarim]

Since you mentioned SGE, I'll make a comparison between SGE and WHM.
So we have a tank pulling big in dungeons but not using mitigation, lots of single target heal required.

...

SGE has a lot more tools than WHM has and is ahead in free healing at every level range, both for ST and aoe healing, even when partly ignoring some of their mechanics/ cooldowns and has better MP economy.

If you struggled so hard on SGE, you probably made some mistakes. Which is fine, but it's not the SGE toolkit that's lacking.

Thanks for the side by side comparison.

But SGE at lvl 71 (Holminster Switch!) has not so much to fall back on, and that's where I caused my first wipe in like...forever? Definitely an experience thing, and me fumbling with the new skills (practiced a little before and did it as trust, but that's obviously not the same). On WHM this would not have happened though, even if I had spent all my instants/OGCDs I would still have Cure II as fallback (not even speaking of Holy). SGE does not have anything like that, making it the worse healer at that point.

You are right though, at max level things will look differently (I am not there yet with SGE). In my experience so far, SGE is excellent for most situations, its just those tight moments that I dread on that class, while I can simple power through them on WHM.