I think that the design around raidwides is nonsensical at best. I can understand that if you're going to give every job the same action, then you just make it a role action, like Reprisal. But then you've got Dark Missionary and Heart of Light, which are magic only, identical to each other, and objectively worse. Meanwhile, the ARR era tanks have big barrier shields that are on the same recast, and work against all damage types. I suspect that a lot of this comes down to the fact that the one person on the development team who actually plays a tank and isn't even involved in job design has yet to actually play one of the newer tanks. It just reflects a complete lack of creativity or interest in the role.