Why is there still no good solution to the housing shortage?

[Shougun]

I'm saying, if you want instanced housing that functions like housing already does... that's not going to relieve any strain on the servers, and housing will still have to be limited.
The only way to do that, the only way to make unlimited housing plots, is to make 'instanced housing' via temporary instances, i.e. Duties.

What you're asking for is impossible.

When someone asks for a job do you respond with "can't that doesn't exist!"

Like.. "of course it doesn't..." lol.. "I'm asking for it TO Exist".

What you're saying is under our current understanding of the game it can't happen. Well.. ... ... obviously..... That's the point of the request. Make it happen. "But it can't" well it clearly can, at least in other games, we know this system it has happened -many- times. "It can't happen in FFXIV" obviously it doesn't right now (or it may be so impractical for them that it really does feel like impossible), but are you god of all things future (in which case, give me an idol so I can praise you.. :3)? Is it for you to decide what SE can and can't do for all time? Even then, if it doesn't happen now can you not imagine some people just never want to see the system again?

I'd love to see a Reaper job.
"Cant we don't have the lore for it, there is no reaper in the game and there will never be a reaper in the game it just doesn't work"
Thank you, I can tell for myself that it's not in the game yet- I'm asking for it 'to be in the game'. Honestly though this back and forth I did see on such a job as well, many people saying it's not possible for reasons they were clearly wrong about.

Clearly a housing system is far more complicated, to the point it would likely cost SE not multiple thousands but far far more, as I said I've limited expectations they would bother with the work to do it here, but I certainly wish it was and or at least done from the beginning in the next system. As this is one of the worst housing 'systems' I've seen in a well received/'popular MMO' (though I imagine their vision would have worked better if it was FC only, which was their original intention).