Tanks Pulling Trains (Who's Wrong?)

[blue_skies]

My mistake. I misunderstood what you had originally said and apologize if my tone came across as accusatory.

This combined with your other updates makes me think it's most likely both you and the tank were undergeared coupled with inadequate CD management on the tank's part. If you use everything before Cure II spam then there's really not much else that can be expected of you. I'd still recommend buying Augmented Scaevan for poetics in Rhalgr's Reach. Healing margins on large pulls can be incredibly tight if the pull goes long (low party dps) or if the tank is undergeared. Having an extra 20% healing output can make all the difference.

I'm re-running it now with a Trust to try and re-create the pulls. The Trust tank isn't taking nearly as much damage and I'm not having any issue weaving Holy.

Here's a screenshot of the equivalent pull (sorry if I'm doing it wrong): https://imgur.com/a/XfamZxu

[Jaelommiss]

I'm re-running it now with a Trust to try and re-create the pulls. The Trust tank isn't taking nearly as much damage and I'm not having any issue weaving Holy.

Here's a screenshot of the equivalent pull (sorry if I'm doing it wrong): https://imgur.com/a/XfamZxu

I did a bit of testing just now. A trust tank takes roughly the same amount of damage as a synced tank does when using CDs. That pull in particular has a mob that needs to be silenced or it will dramatically increase an enemy's damage. There's another mob that uses a decently strong tankbuster every 15-20 seconds. If your tank was undergeared (especially if using right side to inflate ilvl), used CDs poorly, and failed to silence the mob then they would take an impossible amount of damage. It might be survivable with a healer in full i400 gear, but certainly not anything less than that.