A Twightlight Knight Job Class

[Soge01]

I think it's the latter, to which I must ask, what would be the point?

I think it'd be interesting to see. Like how Red Mage switches between Dark and Light magic to build its meter gauge

I feel like introducing a class that does this risks making the class fantasy of drk and pld suffer because it would become a less defining thing for them if another class also heavily uses these specific elements of magic/aether.

However I'm not against the idea itself if the hypothetical class used different elements such as water and lightning. Right now we don't have a class in which these particular elements are what they specifically specialise in clearly far above all other elements. Or maybe we do (?) and I'm wrong but I woke up only a little while ago so perhaps my memory is failing me

The only other job class that uses water and lightning magic is Red Mage, unless you count Blue Mage.

Thinking about what you said, maybe a Twilight Knight could be like Red Mage where it's a less powerful version of both Paladin and Dark Knight in terms of elemental affinity and instead utilizes one element to boost the other when it comes to certain attacks? I'd have to think on what types of attacks it could perform though.

Dual wielding tank job... uhm Judge?

Lol, I completely forgot Gabranth dual wielded! Hmm, now your making me think about how a Magitek Knight Judge could use dark and light magic to bolster its strikes.

Like having one sword attuned to darkness and the other to light and since we've been to both the Void and the First, maybe we could somehow derive the power of darkness from the void and Eden's Sin Eater aspected light to give a Twilight Magitek Judge access both elements...? Lol, while I know that probably wouldn't make much sense to how a Twilight Judge could use dark and light magic maybe something else could help do that though. xD