Quote Originally Posted by ReiMakoto View Post
its clearing fights faster and better
Two things.

1) By coming at it from the angle of contribution, you are simultaneously taking this away from the other roles. What justification can you give that couldn't be used for the other roles against tanks, who also just want "Their piece of the pie"?

What makes "Tank" so deserving of a bigger piece that it must take it from the others?

2) The content is done. If Tanks got any increase in 5.3, content in 5.3 and on will be tuned around it - You'll get your wish for Shiva, but then Not-Ultimecia comes out and you're back where you started.

Enrage timers are not based on only the DPS jobs - They include the tanks and healers. If 5.2 dropped with a 10% increase for tanks, Shiva would have had more health, and it still would have been a 14 minute fight (12, if we're being pedantic)